Valuation, pricing, and performance of initial public offerings on the ghana stock exchange by mohammed sani abdulai llm, university of liverpool, 20 mba, ghana institute of management and public administration, 2009 facca, association of chartered certified accountants, 2004 cat, association of chartered certified accountants, 2001. When forecasted earnings are used for calculating pe ratios, however, the accuracy of the valuation improves substantially. Eventually, the research paper concludes with an illustration of further compelling scientific. The more quantitative a model, the better the valuation truth 3. Impact of fundamentals on ipo valuation rajesh aggarwal sanjai bhagat srinivasan rangan discounted cashflow valuation where, n life of the asset cft cashflow in period t r discount rate reflecting the riskiness of the estimated cashflows motivation early profitability is not the key to value in a company like this inktomi. Sep 11, 2014 damodarans valuation in line with ipo price range damodaran is by no means an alibaba bear. As prelude to setting the offering price in an initial public offering. Weve discussed initial public offering process in detail initial public offering process in detail. The macabacus ipo model implements all concepts related to ipo modeling, including ipo and fully distributed valuation, grossnet proceeds, filing range, primarysecondary shares, underwriters discount gross spread, overallotment option greenshoe, and more. I am given a task to do a valuation of 2 year old investment bank which is private held. Aswath damodaran 3 equity valuation versus firm valuation value just the equity stake in the business value the entire business, which includes, besides equity, the other claimholders in the firm aswath damodaran 4 i. It is based on an assessment of what royalty costs a company is.
It is all relative multiples, comparables and value. But the pricing of many assets has become a more complex task in modern markets, especially after the recent financial crisis. However, the basic language and components of venture capital valuation are universal, simple, and should be well understood before you engage a discussion of valuation with a venture capital investor. Guided by goldman sachs, he felt the market would accord a higher priceearnings multiple to. A sub method of the income or economic benefit method is the relief from royalties method. While traditional analysis is built on the premise that firms in the same sector are comparable firms, valuation theory would suggest that a comparable firm is one which is similar to the one being analyzed in terms of fundamentals. Jetblue airways ipo valuation by chase boyle on prezi. In reality, the process of valuation isnt that easy. I teach corporate finance, valuation and investment philosophies at the stern school of business at new york university. Damodaran, professor of finance at nyus stern school of business, compares a companys life cycle to the human development stages.
A survey of the theory and evidence aswath damodaran stern school of business, new york university, 44 w. Damodaran values lyft ahead of ipo business valuation resources. Using reports from underwriters of their preipo valuation process on 228 ipos on the nyse euronext paris for the years 19901999,17 roosenboom also found that underwriters, in an. Hearn 2011 mentions the lack of attention about ipos valuation and. Ipo lessons for public market investors aswath damodaran. I estimate a compounded revenue growth rate of 40% for the next five years and a scaling down of that growth rate to the nominal. In the last few weeks, we have seen two high profile unicorns file for initial public offerings. Their current strategy is to tout the companys selfdriving car unit. For instance, a selfvaluation done by a target firm in a takeover is likely to be positively biased. How an ipo is valued an initial public offering is the. The professors case was that facebooks price post the cambridge analytica. The numbers, what the model tells you dont have time to explain the process in detail here plan. Aswath damodaran says valuation is not just a number, theres. Aswath damodaran on facebook, valuation, and faith podcast.
In this paper, we examine how best to value young companies. Fte, other valuation tools multiplespremiums in precedent transactions, breakup values, and calculation of terminal values. The reason for such large valuation errors is simple. May 10, 2019 the uber ipo is finally upon us, and it has proved divisive. When using a valuation done by a third party, the biases of the analysts doing the valuation should be considered before decisions are made on its basis. Part 2 applies these ideas to typical valuation situations.
In todays class, we put the finishing touches on private company valuation by looking at key questions that arise in private company valuation illiquidity, key person etc. Aswath damodaran on facebook, valuation, and faith. Assume that an analyst is valuing an initial public offering of a firm that manufactures computer software. The first out of the gate was dropbox, a storage solution for a world where gigabyte files are the rule rather than the exception, with a filing on february 23. Damodaran values lyft ahead of ipo business valuation. Pdf on oct 12, 2015, ewa dziwok and others published sensitivity analysis of.
Ipos, and two studies that focus on the accuracy of ipo valuation. Greater the postipo ownership, and smaller the sales by each of these four categories of owners greater the ipo valuation. This is a great case study of the spotify ipo, showing how it differs to the standard big business ipos and how that works for spotify. I was told to do the valuation as if the company is going public.
Cash flow methods of ipo equity valuation, journal of international financial. The historically low 10 year rate will drive the valuation higher than a scenario where inflation returns in the near term. Pdf on oct 12, 2015, ewa dziwok and others published sensitivity analysis of ipo valuation for startup companies find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. This is something to keep in mind if you plan to discount for risktime. Usually, they are sold at the price at which the buyer would like to buy.
Jetblue airways ipo valuation case solution and analysis. Finally, i estimate equity beta using an industry average of public firms in the ipos market space. Stay connected to your students with prezi video, now in microsoft teams. The case outlines jetblues innovative strategy and the associated strong financial performance over its initial two years. Valuation methodologies differ by the stage of investment and the availability of quantitative and qualitative data. Korean company kakao that was considering an ipo focus. Ipo lessons for public market investors in my post on the peloton ipo, i opined on how venture capitalists price companies and how the pressures that they have put on companies to scale up quickly, often without paying heed to building good business models, is playing out. Yourunderstanding of a valuation model is inversely proportional to the number of inputs required for the model. Aswath damodaran 9 application tests n given the firm that we are valuing, what is a comparable firm. Nov 28, 2016 in todays class, we put the finishing touches on private company valuation by looking at key questions that arise in private company valuation illiquidity, key person etc. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Valuation, pricing, and performance of initial public. The process of valuing private companies is not different from the process of. Ipo valuation methods, models and variables discussion.
Jetblue airways ipo valuation case solution and analysis, hbr. The price of an ipo is decided by the supply and demand of the trade market. Private company for initial public offering nyu stern. Hype and fundamentals while the financial world debates the handling of facebooks much anticipated and heavily publicized ipo, the use of several different valuation methods illustrates that. You can value a private business for sale by one individual to another private to public transactions. Pdf sensitivity analysis of ipo valuation for startup. Pdf sensitivity analysis of ipo valuation for startup companies. Companies strive to maximise profits and they do ipo allotment basics. In order to be successful at this endeavor, you must have a firm understanding of the proper valuation techniques. Valuation guru aswath damodaran says companies, like human beings, have a life cycle and a firms valuation should be able to reflect its position in the lifecycle. Aswath damodaran says valuation is not just a number. Valuation is at the heart of any investment decision, whether that decision is buy, sell or hold. The process of valuing private companies is not different from the. A little more than a week ago, i posted my first take on twitter and argued that even in the absence of financial information from the company since the prospectus had not been filed yet, you could price the company.
At the same time, the priceearnings multiples of other. The valuation a little more than a week ago, i posted my first take on twitter and argued that even in the absence of financial information from the company since the prospectus had not been filed yet, you could price the company. A valuation is an objective search for truevalue truth 1. The payoff to valuation is greatest when valuation is least precise. Based on prior transactions in the company vc infusions and acquisitions and the multiples of revenuesusers for other companies in the. The uber ipo is finally upon us, and it has proved divisive. The market imperative relative valuation is much more likely to re. This can be an advantage when it is important that the price re.
I am a fan of aswath damodarans damodaran on valuation, 2nd edition, wiley publishing, 2006. Aswath damodaran investment valuation easyonlinebooks. May 14, 20 ipo model template description the macabacus ipo model implements all concepts related to ipo modeling, including ipo and fully distributed valuation, grossnet proceeds, filing range, primarysecondary shares, underwriters discount gross spread, overallotment option greenshoe, and more. You can value a private firm for an initial public.
The direction and magnitude of the bias in your valuation is directly proportional to who pays you and how much you are paid. Managing general partner, boston millennia partners michael larsen, senior associate, life sciences introduction you have met with several venture firms, responded to countless due diligence inquiries, and a. You can value a division or divisions of a publicly traded. Ipo valuation initial public offering valuation finance. To do a sumoftheparts valuation to determine whether a. For instance, a self valuation done by a target firm in a takeover is likely to be positively biased. Jetblue jblu wanted to go to ipo in order to raise additional capital. The critics point to ubers billiondollar losses and sec filings so meager, a financial times commentary called them an. An ipo is an offer of shares of ipo valuation indepth guide. Private company valuation nyu stern school of business. This case examines the april 2002 decision of jetblue management to price the initial public offering of jetblue stock during one of the worst periods in airline history.
The only questions are how much and in which direction. Jetblue airways ipo valuation jetblue airways ipo valuation borislav belenov, wade brashear, jamie clausen, paul collier, nicole hagan and melissa lein managerial finance chadron state college professor steve stoner may 2009 david neeleman is the founder of jetblue airways, which began under the name of new air in 1999. To figure out where that leaves the rest of us nyu finance professor aswath damodaran revisits his valuation of alibaba and finds the. Damodaran method, first chicago method, real option valuation, intangibles valuation, bill paynes scorecard method, airbnb case study, airbnb. In an initial public offering, the private business is opened up to investors. Equity valuation the value of equity is obtained by discounting expected cashflows to equity, i. Damodaran 1994 points out that the dividend discount model is a. Jetblue airways ipo valuation jetblue airways ipo valuation borislav belenov, wade brashear, jamie clausen, paul collier, nicole hagan and melissa lein managerial finance chadron state college professor steve stoner may 2009 david neeleman is the founder of jetblue airways, which began under the. An initial public offering ipo is the process by which a privatelyowned enterprise is transformed into a public company whose shares are traded on a.
1655 385 1182 153 726 910 827 485 1465 705 942 386 696 413 603 302 120 1628 668 1381 1041 1134 1366 302 1586 1566 1657 453 349 1139 614 547 923 531 1169 1211 132